Investigation of the relationship between occupational cognitive failures and work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee port complex
Reza Jafari Nodoushan1, Afarin Akhavan2, Mohammad Esmaeeli Miyanshahri3, Vida Sadat Anoosheh4
1 Department of Occupational Health Engineering, School of Public Health, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran
2 Department of Industrial Engineering, Science and Arts University, Yazd, Iran
3 M.Sc Student of Industrial Safety, Science and Arts University, Yazd, Iran
4 M.Sc Student of Ergonomics, School of Public Health, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran
|Date of Submission||10-Oct-2019|
|Date of Acceptance||20-Mar-2020|
|Date of Web Publication||28-Jul-2020|
Ms. Vida Sadat Anoosheh
M.Sc Student of Ergonomics, School of Public Health, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
INTRODUCTION: Occupational accidents have many undesirable and irreparable effects on labor forces, assets, environment, and credibility of organizations. Human errors are one of the most important causes of occupational accidents. Human errors have different causes, but in all cases, human cognitive abilities and limitations play important roles; in this research, the relationship between occupational cognitive failures and work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex has been investigated.
METHODS: This research was done through the field method. A sample of 332 people was selected by a stratified sampling method among all heavy equipment operators. The data gathering tool contained a 30-item occupational cognitive failure questionnaire. Furthermore, regression analysis method was used to test the hypotheses.
RESULTS: The results of this study showed that cognitive failures of occupational accidents on direct work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port complex have a direct effect (P < 0.00). Further more, variables that modify the research are age, work experience, working hours, educational level, type of occupation, and marital status of the operators.
CONCLUSION: Regarding the direct relation between cognitive occupational failures and occupational accidents, one can predictive this result that the occupational cognitive failure questionnaire can be used as a predictive tool in accidents of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex.
Keywords: Cognitive failure, occupational accidents heavy equipment operators
|How to cite this article:|
Nodoushan RJ, Akhavan A, Miyanshahri ME, Anoosheh VS. Investigation of the relationship between occupational cognitive failures and work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee port complex. J Edu Health Promot 2020;9:189
|How to cite this URL:|
Nodoushan RJ, Akhavan A, Miyanshahri ME, Anoosheh VS. Investigation of the relationship between occupational cognitive failures and work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee port complex. J Edu Health Promot [serial online] 2020 [cited 2021 May 11];9:189. Available from: https://www.jehp.net/text.asp?2020/9/1/189/290944
| Introduction|| |
Accidents are one of the phenomena that have been spreading along with the industrialization and advancement of technology, which not only imposes many human and financial losses but also to human societies. Many of the work processes in industrial organizations have potentially catastrophic consequences for workers and the environment. Occupational accidents and injuries are one of the causes of worries of workers and employers due to the costs of treatment and unemployment, as, each year, 25 million workers are subject to occupational accidents and illnesses. In general, the events result in the loss of physical and mental health, time and money, and, in some cases, irreparable damages. In other words, human costs are so expensive and far-reaching that they cannot be estimated. An incident is an unplanned event that may result in damage. Occupational injury causes physical injuries to the employees, in such a way that its range begins with cuts and superficial injuries resulting in organ failure and death.
Various researchers have looked at different types of occupational accidents. Some have tried to identify all incident predictions, and others have emphasized only a few of them. Most occupational safety-related researches emphasize the two elements of insecure conditions and the individual characteristics of workers in the event of accidents. Recent studies show that there are a number of personality traits that are associated with incidents, but many of these attributes are largely independent of each other. In all of these studies, human factors are considered as one of the most important causes of occupational accidents although the work environment conditions and the nature of occupational tasks also play a role in the incident. Among these factors are the cognitive factors that have recently attracted the attention of psychologists. Although the effect of knowing on events is less evident, it must be emphasized that cognitive factors play a significant role in causing events. Cognitive failures can be defined by errors with a cognitive basis in performing simple tasks that one can perform without mistakes. These mistakes may occur in one or all three stages of the process of processing information: memory, attention, and action. Cognitive impairments can lead to major problems due to interference with daily activities. When these errors occur in triggering actions, they may cause serious injury and even death. Research has discovered that there is a relationship between cognitive deficits, anxiety, psychological stress, fatigue, sleepiness, and emotional disturbances. Recently, safety-related studies have been designed to investigate the influence of cognitive processes in incidents. For example, a study by Petitta et al., in 2019 on the effects of cognitive failures in incidents, showed a positive correlation between incidence rates and cognitive deficits. In another study, Wallace and Vodanovich examined the relationship between cognitive failures with three variables of occupational accidents, occupational evaluation, and car accident rates. The results showed that the total score of cognitive impairments had a positive and significant relationship with the rate of car accidents, occupational accidents, and performance evaluation scores of the individuals.
Considering the fact that few studies have been done in Iran regarding the association of occupational cognitive failures with work-related incidents in industrial environments so far, this is the first time that the investigation of the relationship between occupational cognitive failures and work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex is performed.
| Methods|| |
Considering the aims and objectives of this field research, the data were collected from 332 out of 2430 heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex using the Cochran sampling formula. Due to the nature of the heavy equipments, operators and their categorization in Gentry crane and Port Container Gantry Crane groups, forklift operators, crane operators and drivers from all groups, the samples of the population were selected by stratified sampling method. For the development of our research literature, library studies including books, journals, articles, and theses related to our research topic were used. A standardized questionnaire was used as our data gathering tool in our research. The questionnaire of this research consists of two parts. The first part relates to the measurement of demographic variables and the number of accidents occurred in the individuals, and the second part relates to the measurement of occupational cognitive failure variables that was presented by Broadbent et al., and its reliability was verified by Dr. Allahyari et al. in 2012. The questionnaire contains 30 questions that the respondents answer to them in the form of a Likert spectrum. The mean of these questions is considered as the criterion of the extent of the cognitive decline of the respondent and its impact on the work-related accidents of the individuals being examined. In addition to formal validity, the content validity of the questionnaire was confirmed by experts, and its reliability was obtained through Cronbach's alpha coefficient equal to 0.875, indicating good tool reliability.
| Results|| |
Among 332 samples taken from heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex, 167 (50.3%) of them were between the ages of 30–39 years and 118 (35.5%) had a history of 10–14 years of work experience, and among the occupational categories, 89 employees (26.8%) were Gantry crane and Gonteri and Trans Operator, 62 (18.7%) Forklifts operators, 15 (4.5%) crane operators, and 166 (50%) lorry drivers.
[Table 1] shows the average of occupational cognitive failures and the number of accidents in different groups of demographic variables. The highest mean of cognitive impairment and the average number of incidents related to operators of <30 years age (1.09 and 2.31), the most cognitive failure relates to 5–9 years work experience operators (0.61 and 2.08), the highest mean of occupational failures and average number of incidents relate to lorry drivers (1.12 and 2.18).
|Table 1: Occupational cognitive failure and number of accidents in different groups of demographic variables|
Click here to view
[Table 2] shows that occupational cognitive failures on work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of the Shahid Rajaee Port Complex have a significant positive/negative effect. Considering that the confidence coefficient obtained in the regression analysis is <0.05, there is a significant relationship between occupational cognitive impairment and work-related accidents. Therefore, it can be concluded that occupational cognitive impairments have an impact on work-related accidents in the heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex. Regarding the sign and the amount of the independent variable coefficient (B), this effect is positive and its rate is 0.975.
|Table 2: Relationship between occupational cognitive failures on work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex|
Click here to view
[Table 3] shows the relationship between the operators' ages and occupational cognitive failures of work-related occupational incidents in heavy equipments of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex. It also shows the confident coefficient obtained from regression analysis in all age groups is less than 0.05 in all groups. which has a significent relationship with comparison independent variable coefficient with group B. The regression in all groups is significant, The comparing amounts of independent coefficient variable B in all groups shows that the operators' age and the role of occupational cognitive failures on work-related inccidents in operators of heavy equipments. As it can be seen, the effect of occupational cognitive failures on work-related iccidents in the age group of <30 years is more than other age groups with the a mount of 1.986.
|Table 3: The relationship between age of operators occupational cognitive failure with work-related accidents of heavy equipment in Shahid Rajaee Port Complex|
Click here to view
[Table 4] shows the relationship between the work experience of the operator regarding occupational cognitive failures of work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex, considering that the confidence coefficient obtained in regression analysis in the age group of <5 years from 0.05 is more than regression and is not meaningful.
|Table 4: Relationship between the work experience of the operator and the occupational cognitive failures of work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex|
Click here to view
In the group over 20 years of age, a regression cannot be applied due to the fact that the values of the dependent variable are constant. However, the confidence coefficient obtained in regression analysis in all working groups is <0.05. Regression has a meaningful relationship in all groups. Comparing the values of the independent variable coefficient (B) in the groups shows that the work experience of the operator has an impact on the role of occupational cognitive failures in accidents caused by the heavy equipment operators of the Shahid Rajaee Port Complex. As can be seen, the effect of occupational cognitive failures on work-related accidents in a group with a work experience of 9–5 years with an effect of 1.378 is more than other age groups.
According to [Table 5] the relationship between the operator's working hours and the effect of occupational cognative failour on work-related inccidents show that the amount of confident co-efficient obtained from regression analysis is less than 0.05 in the two groups, therefore regression in two groups is significant. Comparison of the independent variable of coefficient values (B) in the two groups shows that the operator's work hours affect the role of occupational cognitive failures of work-related accidents in the heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex. As can be seen, the effect of occupational cognitive failures on work-related accidents in the working-time group is up to 8 h a day, with an impact level of 1.253 is more than the other groups.
|Table 5: Relationship between operator's work hours and occupational cognitive failures of work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex|
Click here to view
[Table 6] shows the relationship between the operator's education and work-related cognitive failures with work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex. Since the confidence level obtained in regression analysis is <0.05 for all educational levels except for the bachelor's degree, regression is significant in those groups. In the group of bachelor's degree, since the value of the coefficient of confidence is >0.05, the regression is not significant. Comparison of independent variable coefficient values (B) in groups shows that operator's education affects the role of occupational cognitive failures on work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex. As can be seen, the effect of occupational cognitive failures on work-related accidents in the diploma group with an impact level of 1.264 is more than other groups.
|Table 6: Relationship between operator educations on the occupational cognitive failures of work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex|
Click here to view
[Table 7] shows the relationship between the operator type of job and occupational cognitive failures in work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex. As the amount of reliability obtained in regression analysis in all occupational groups is <0.05, regression is significant. The comparison of independent variable coefficient values (B) in groups shows that the type of job affects the role of occupational failures on work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex. As can be seen, the effect of occupational cognitive failures on work-related accidents in a group of lorry drivers with an impact level of 0.859 is more than other groups.
|Table 7: Relationship between the types of operator's job on occupational cognitive failures in work-related accidents in heavy equipment operators of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex|
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
The incidence of accidents in the various countries of the world, especially in the industrial sectors, is relatively high, and over time, it continues to increase, with 260 million incidents leading to injuries and 250,000 deaths in jobs. The impact which has cognitive impairments on occupational accidents, led to this study with the general aim of investigating the relationship between occupational cognitive failures and accidents. The results of this study showed that the impact of occupational cognitive failures on work-related accidents is positive. If one unit increases/decreases in occupational cognitive deficits, 0.975 will be decreased/increased to the number of incidents. The results of studies such as the study of Larson and Merritt on motorcycle accidents and cognitive deficits in 1991 showed a positive correlation between incidents and occupational defects. Furthermore, the study of Wallace and Vodanovich showed that the total score of cognitive failures with the rate of car accidents, occupational accidents, and the performance evaluation score of the individuals has a positive and significant relationship with the present study. Another study by Allahyari et al., in 2014, with the occupational cognitive failure questionnaire on the personnel of a large industrial company, showed that there is a positive relationship between cognitive failures and personnel's accidents in a large industrial company in Iran. Furthermore, another study by Allahyari et al. in 2008 showed that cognitive failures have a high correlation with drivers' mistakes in the driving simulator. Wadsworth et al. investigated the effect of cognitive impairment (memory, attention, or practice problems) in the event of accidents and injuries, which indicates a direct association of cognitive dissonance with events. The results of the study by O'hare et al. showed that there is a significant relationship between cognitive errors and accidents. In a study, Park and Kim et al. reviewed 279 nurses in the same year to examine the impact of stress and cognitive error on the safety of patients. The factors that affect incidents are job change, cognitive failure, job insecurity, and job instability.
According to our study, the greatest impact of occupational cognitive failures on work-related accidents is on the age group of <30 years with work experience of 5–9 years. Regarding the effect of moderating variables on the relationship between occupational cognitive deficits, few studies have been conducted on accidents. The study of Abolghasemi and Kiamarsi, in 2009, showed that the aging of individuals has a significant impact on their cognitive performance; possibly, it increases cognitive function. Due to the fact that this study was done on the elderly, the results are not consistent with our study. However, the research done by Brati and Arizi in 2015 showed that the relationship between cognitive deficits and age is negative and the relationship between metacognition and age is positive. Furthermore, age, negative beliefs, cognitive trust, and carelessness explain cognitive deficits. These results are consistent with the results of Wallace and Vodanovich. This could be due to the fact that the age growth of using metacognition (the knowledge of the evaluation, monitoring, and control of knowledge) increases and these elements reduce cognitive impairment. Using metacognition can also explain the negative impact of work experience and shift work on the relationship between occupational cognitive failures and work-related accidents. Individuals with diploma education had also more cognitive failures because of less familiarity with the principles of safety in attention and practice, and the lorry drivers, due to the repetition and uniformity of their work, suffered more from cognitive decline in attention, memory, and practice than other operators and they had more incidents. Married operators are also less likely to experience cognitive impairment and occupational accidents due to their orientation and concentration.
| Conclusion|| |
Considering the results obtained in this study, it can be concluded that cognitive impairment has a direct relationship with work accidents and is the most significant mean of cognitive impairment in work-related accidents in lorry drivers. Hence, this occupational is very important. In the case of lorry drivers, the more accurate implementation of the periodic examination process can be beneficial. Physical, physiological, and psychological factors of operators that have an effective role in the occurrence of accidents must further be studied.
Considering that occupational cognitive failures and incidents in operators of <30 years and those who had less work experience was more than the others, thus, it can be foreseen that the training courses must be held to prevent such incidents. Furthermore, metacognitive teaching such as monitoring, evaluating and betterment of learning strategies and solving problems can be effective. It was also seen that occupational cognitive failures are more common in individuals who hold diplomas and upper educational status is more than the other groups. Therefore, training courses can be used to ensure safety and work principles. In addition, operators with a bachelor's degree who have less cognitive impairment should be put into the night shift to prevent accidents.
In the case of shift work, managers can come up with solutions that the individuals must be employed according to their conditions to use their physical and intellectual capacities. They should also provide a mechanism for the job rotation system based on the approved scientific principles. Hence, according to the results of this study, we can use occupational cognition failures to predict the incidence of accidents.
We are greatly obliged and thankful to the manager and responsible staff of the Heavy Equipment Department of Shahid Rajaee Port Complex. It should be pointed out that this paper is based on a master thesis at Science and Arts University and it was found to be in accordance to the ethical principles and the national norms by the code of ethics IR.ACECR.JDM.REC.1399.004.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Kim T, Chi S. Accident case retrieval and analyses: Using natural language processing in the construction industry. J Construct Engin Manage 2019, 145.3: 04019004
Niu S. Ergonomics and occupational safety and health: An ILO perspective. Appl Ergon 2010, 41.6: 744-753.
Tamers SL, Chosewood LC, Childress A, Hudson H, Nigam J, Chang CC. Total Worker Health® 2014-2018: The novel approach to worker safety, health, and well-being evolves. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2019;16: 321.
Earle AM, Napper LE, LaBrie JW, Brooks-Russell A, Smith DJ, de Rutte J. Examining interactions within the theory of planned behavior in the prediction of intentions to engage in cannabis-related driving behaviors. J Am Coll Health 2019:1-7.
Bergheim, K., Nielsen, M. B., Mearns, K., & Eid, J. The relationship between psychological capital, job satisfaction, and safety perceptions in the maritime industry. Safety Sci 2015;74:27-36.
Hussain, S., Batool, I., Bano, S., & Ali, H. Emotional climate, work stress and occupational cognitive failure in doctors. Peshawar J Psychol Behav Sci 2018, 4.2: 221-235.
Simpson SA, Wadsworth EJ, Moss SC, Smith AP. Minor injuries, cognitive failures and accidents at work: Incidence and associated features. Occup Med (Lond) 2005;55:99-108.
van Doorn RR, Lang JW, Weijters T. Self-reported cognitive failures: A core self-evaluation? Pers Individ Diff 2010, 49.7: 717-722.
Mecacci L, Righi S. Cognitive failures, metacognitive beliefs and aging. Pers Individ Diff 2006;40.7:1453-9.
Petitta L, Probst TM, Ghezzi V, Barbaranelli C. Cognitive failures in response to emotional contagion: Their effects on workplace accidents. Accid Anal Prev,2019, 125: 165-173
Wallace JC, Vodanovich SJ. Workplace safety performance: Conscientiousness, cognitive failure, and their interaction. J Occup Health Psychol 2003;8:316.
Broadbent DE, Cooper PF, FitzGerald P, Parkes KR. The Cognitive Failures Questionnaire (CFQ) and its correlates. Br J Clin Psychol 1982;21:1-6.
Hassanzadeh Rangi, N., Allahyari, T., Khosravi, Y., Zaeri, F., & Saremi, M. Development of an Occupational Cognitive Failure Questionnaire (OCFQ): Evaluation validity and reliability. Iran Occup Health 2012;9:29-40.
Hämäläinen P, Takala J, Saarela KL. Global estimates of occupational accidents. Safety Sci 2006;44:137-156.
Allahyari T, Rangi NH, Khalkhali H, Khosravi Y. Occupational cognitive failures and safety performance in the workplace. Int J Occup Saf Ergon 2014;20:175-180.
Larson GE, Merritt CR. Can accidents be predicted? An empirical test of the Cognitive Failures Questionnaire. Applied Psychol 1991;40:37-45.
Allahyari, T., Saraji, G. N., Adi, J., Hosseini, M., Iravani, M., Younesian, M., & Kass, S. J. Cognitive failures, driving errors and driving accidents. Int J Occup Saf Ergon 2008;14:149-158.
Wadsworth EJ, Simpson SA, Moss SC, Smith AP. The Bristol Stress and Health Study: Accidents, minor injuries and cognitive failures at work. Occup Med (Lond) 2003;53:392-397.
O'HARE DA, Wiggins M, Batt R, Morrison D. Cognitive failure analysis for aircraft accident investigation. Ergonomics 1994;37(11):1855-69.
Park YM, Kim SY. Impacts of job stress and cognitive failure on patient safety incidents among hospital nurses. Saf Health Work 2013;4:210-215.
ABOLGHASEMI, Abbas; KIAMARSI, Azar. The Relationship between metacognition and cognitive failures in the elderly. Advances in Cognitive Science 2009;11:8-15.
Barati H, Oreyzi SS. Relation between Cognitive Failures and Cognitive Beliefs in Life Span Considering thought Control; 2015:235-251.
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4], [Table 5], [Table 6], [Table 7]